BLOGS

Why unsubscribers are doing your email marketing a favour

Why unsubscribers are doing your email marketing a favour

You hit send on your latest campaign, job done! Time for a coffee. And then you come back to find 14 people have unsubscribed, cue the spiral. There used to be a time when big email lists were seen as something to celebrate, but when we dig a little deeper into why, we think that belief is flawed. We’re gonna be chatting about the people leaving, and why they might be doing you a favour. 

In this post:

  • Bigger isn’t better
  • What an unsubscribe is really telling you
  • Why dead weight hurts your inbox
  • What a healthy unsubscribe rate looks like
  • When it’s time to worry
  • How to tidy up your list
  • Quick questions about unsubscribes
  • Go fourth and conquer

Bigger isn’t better 

Think of your list like a Spotify playlist with 500 songs on it. It looks quite impressive, but you skip most of them and only ever hit repeat on a handful. A list full of people who never open, click, or buy is the same sort of thing.

Many platforms also charge by the number of contacts on your list, so you could be paying to email people who haven’t opened a thing. How your email platform counts unsubscribed and inactive contacts varies, and we’ve broken down how Klaviyo, Omnisend, and Mailchimp compare if you’re weighing up options. 

What an unsubscribe is really telling you 

Someone unsubscribing is a polite “yeah nah”. They’ve told you straight that they won’t be buying, so you can stop spending effort on them. That’s honest feedback you’d normally pay for in a survey. It also means the percentage of people opening and clicking your emails goes up, because the ones who were never going to engage have left the building. 

Why dead weight hurts your inbox 

Inbox providers pay attention to how people engage with your emails. Email platforms like Omnisend explain that a pile of subscribers who never engage can drag down your sender reputation, which makes it harder for your emails to land in anyone’s inbox.

What a healthy unsubscribe rate looks like 

Mailchimp says a good unsubscribe rate generally sits below 0.5% per campaign. Other benchmark reports land in a similar range, though averages shift depending on the industry and how each report measures it. So 14 unsubscribes from a list of 5,000 works out to 0.28%. Right on the money, and no panic required. 

When it’s time to worry 

A steady trickle is normal, and a sudden spike is worth a look, especially after one particular email or after you’ve bumped up how often you’re sending. If a single send goes above that 0.5% rule of thumb it’s time to check the subject line, the offer, and whether the email matched what people signed up for. Subject lines do a lot of the heavy lifting here too, so our 8 tips for better subject lines are a good place to start. And if you’re really stuck, then have a look at our email marketing services.

How to tidy up your list 

Give your list a clean out every once in a while like you would with your wardrobe floor. Be ruthless, but fair. 

  • Spot the quiet ones. Pull out everyone who hasn’t opened or clicked in the last six months, which is the window most email platforms suggest.
  • Send a re-engagement sequence. A few friendly emails over a couple of weeks, giving them a reason to stay.
  • Let go of the silent ones. If they still don’t bite, remove or archive them.
  • Watch your results after the clean out. A smaller, warmer list is the goal.

Quick questions about unsubscribes

  1. What’s a normal unsubscribe rate? Mailchimp’s rule of thumb is below 0.5% per campaign. A steady trickle under that is nothing to lose sleep over.
  2. Should I remove inactive subscribers? Yes, but give them a chance to stay first with a short re-engagement sequence. Anyone who still doesn’t respond can go.
  3. Can I stop people unsubscribing? No, and you wouldn’t want to. A smaller list of people who want to hear from you beats a bigger one full of strangers.

Go forth and conquer

A tidy list of people who want to hear from you is what you want to aim for. The ones who wander off save you time, money, and a bit of inbox reputation on their way out. As a digital marketing agency with email marketing experts on the team, we help businesses build lists that actually pay their way. If yours needs a good clean out, or you want a second set of eyes before the next send, let’s have a chat. 


Secret Link